Sunday, May 01, 2011

Thanks to Howard Jacobson on his 'The Promise' Piece

Howard Jacobson:

As a boy I felt fraught during the Passover service because it seemed that even as we celebrated a narrow escape from one disaster, we were preparing for the next. A Jew has either to be ignorant of his history or mad to suppose that what has happened before won't happen again.

...Anti-Zionists can assure me all they like that their position entails no harm to Jews - only witness how many Jews are themselves anti-Zionist, they say - I no longer believe them...
Forget Holocaust denial. Holocaust denial is old hat. The new strategy - it showed its hand in Caryl Churchill's Seven Jewish Children, and surfaced again in Channel 4's recent series The Promise - is to depict the Holocaust in all its horror in order that Jews can be charged ("You, of all people") with failing to live up to it.

By this logic the Holocaust becomes an educational experience from which Jews were ethically obliged to graduate summa cum laude, Israel being the proof that they didn't. "Jews know more than anyone that killing civilians is wrong," resounds an unmistakably authorial voice in The Promise.

Thus, are Jews doubly damned: to the Holocaust itself and to the moral wasteland of having found no humanising redemption in its horrors.

It matters not a jot to me that the writer/director of The Promise is a Jew...In a morally intelligent world - that's to say one in which, for starters, Jews are not judged more harshly than their fellows for having been despatched to concentration camps - The Promise would be seen for the ludicrous piece of brainwashed prejudice it is.

Ofcom's rejection of complaints about the drama's partiality and inaccuracy was to be expected. You can't expect a body as intellectually unsophisticated as Ofcom to adjudicate between claims of dramatic truth and truth of any other sort...its finding that The Promise was "serious television drama, not presented as a historical and faithful re-creation", is a poor shot at making sense of anything.

You can't brush aside historical re-creation in a work of historical re-creation, nor can you assert a thing is "serious television" when its seriousness is what's in question. A work isn't serious by virtue of its thinking it is...From start to finish, The Promise was art with its trousers round its ankles. Yes, it looked expensive, took its time, was beautifully shot and well acted. But these are merely the superficies of art, and the more dangerously seductive for that. "Gosh, I never knew such and such had happened," I heard people say after one or other simplifying episode, as though high production values guarantee veracity.

...Just about every Palestinian was sympathetic to look at, just about every Jew was not...Juxtaposition counts for much in art, and when every juxtaposition - of beauty, wealth, humanity, kindliness, suffering - favours one party to the conflict at the expense of another, the simplicity of view begins to show itself in uninventiveness and repetition.

Though I, too, have found Palestinians to be people of immense charm, I could only laugh in derision at The Promise every time another shot of soft-eyed Palestinians followed another shot of hard-faced Jews.

As for the politics, they were as transparently simple-minded as the casting. An act of violence carried out by a Palestinian was shown to be no different in motive and ambition from an act of violence carried out by a Jew...But then of moral equivalence of any sort, except when anti-Jewish propaganda required it, The Promise was bare. Therefore, I say to Ofcom, no, the drama was not serious. It only looked serious because it said what the consensus says. The truth is now nailed to the floor. Jews went through hell only to build a hell for others. Trying arguing otherwise and you are an apologist for that hell.

We have been here before. Dayenu: it would have been enough had God done no more than help us out the last time. But it won't ever be enough...

That was more than enough, Howard.  Thank you.

2 comments:

aparatchik said...

Powerful stuff

Juniper in the Desert said...

Unfortunately, Howard Jacobson used to be a an anti-Zionist Jew, in the 1970's and 1980's. One of those trendy lefty BBC-courting "intellectuals" who thought they could just be "exotically" Jewish. It is only as the next potential Holocaust looms, he has woken up and pretends to have always been this way. I loathe him and have utter contempt for him, as he makes no mention of his former "madness"!